On November 24, 1832, the Convention of the People of South Carolina approved the South Carolina Ordinance of Nullification, precipitating a constitutional crisis that nearly triggered a civil war in the United States.
Summary of the Nullification Crisis
The Nullification Crisis of 1832 was a political dispute between the Federal Government and the government of South Carolina over tariffs that were designed to protect manufacturers in the Northern states who were competing with British manufacturers. The tariffs imposed heavy taxes on British products, which hurt the economies of the Southern states. In 1832, South Carolina responded to the tariffs by a proclamation known as the South Carolina Ordinance of Nullification, which challenged the authority of the Federal Government by nullifying the tariffs and declaring them unconstitutional. As the dispute escalated, South Carolina also threatened to secede. President Andrew Jackson responded by issuing a proclamation that made it clear he intended to preserve the Union and he also sent troops to Charleston. Senators Henry Clay and John C. Calhoun brokered the Compromise Tariff of 1833, which helped bring the crisis over tariffs to an end.
History of the Nullification Crisis
Congress Passes the Tariff of Abominations
On May 19, 1828, United States President John Quincy Adams approved an act of Congress commonly known as the Tariff of 1828. Congress designed the legislation to raise revenue for the federal government by imposing duties (taxes) on manufactured products and some raw materials imported into the United States. Many Americans referred to the law as the Tariff of Abominations, because its provisions protected manufacturers in the Northeast and farmers in the West, at the expense of Southerners and New Englanders. The tariff impacted the South severely because its cotton-based economy, combined with limited manufacturing, dictated a high dependency on imported items.
Tariff of 1832
By 1832, Congress became more receptive to Southern grievances regarding the Tariff of Abominations. On July 14, 1832, Congress enacted — and President Andrew Jackson approved — a new tariff commonly known as the Tariff of 1832. Although the new law reduced or eliminated some protective measures adopted in 1828, it did not go far enough to appease many Southerners, especially in South Carolina.
South Carolina Ordinance of Nullification
The lower duties enacted in the Tariff of 1832 did not placate firebrands in the South. At the urging of U. S. Vice-President John C. Calhoun and U. S. Senator Robert Hayne, South Carolina Governor James Hamilton, Jr., called a special session of the state legislature in 1832. On October 25, the legislature enacted a measure authorizing a statewide convention to consider a response to the enactment of the Tariff of 1832.
The Convention of the People of South Carolina convened in Columbia on November 19, 1832. On November 24, by a vote of 136 to twenty-six, the delegates endorsed a proclamation drafted by William Harper entitled, “An ordinance to nullify certain acts of the Congress of the United States,” purporting to be laws laying duties and imposts on the importation of foreign commodities.
More commonly known as the South Carolina Ordinance of Nullification, the report declared that both the Tariff of 1828 and the Tariff of 1832 were unconstitutional and that the citizens of South Carolina considered them to “be held utterly null and void.” Seeking to punctuate the seriousness of their resolve, the convention members concluded the document by declaring that in response to “any act authorizing the employment of a military or naval force against the State of South Carolina . . . the people of this State will henceforth hold themselves absolved from all further obligation to maintain or preserve their political connection with the people of the other States; and will forthwith proceed to organize a separate government.”
The convention adjourned on November 24, 1832, and distributed copies of the ordinance to President Jackson and the governor of each state in the Union. The South Carolina legislature then busied itself crafting laws necessary to carry the Nullification Ordinance into effect. On December 20, the legislature passed “An Act to carry into effect in part, an Ordinance to Nullify certain Acts of the Congress of the United States.”
President Jackson Responds
President Jackson responded on December 10, 1832, with a proclamation nearly 9,000 words long, stating that:
I consider, then, the power to annul a law of the United States, assumed by one State, incompatible with the existence of the Union, contradicted expressly by the letter of the Constitution, unauthorized by its spirit, inconsistent with every principle on which It was founded, and destructive of the great object for which it was formed.
While Jackson was somewhat conciliatory about the possibility of reducing duties, he insisted that “The Constitution of the United States . . . forms a government, not a league,” thus any perceived right to secede “does not break a league, but destroys the unity of a nation.” Jackson proclaimed his resolve “to execute the laws (and) to preserve the Union by all constitutional means,” including “recourse to force; and . . . the shedding of a brother’s blood,” if necessary.
To ensure that Southern firebrands did not take his warning this warning as an idle threat, Jackson sent General Winfield Scott to Charleston to take charge of federal troops garrisoned in South Carolina. Jackson also moved the U. S. Customs Office in Charleston to Castle Pinckney in Charleston Harbor, and he dispatched seven naval vessels to safeguard that facility.
South Carolina Threatens to Secede
President Jackson’s proclamation prompted the South Carolina legislature to approve a response on December 20, 1833. The fifth of eleven resolutions specified in the response reaffirmed the state’s position:
That each state of the Union has the right, whenever it may deem such a course necessary for the preservation of its liberties or vital interests, to secede peaceably from the Union, and that there is no constitutional power in the general government, much less in the executive department, of that government, to retain by force such state in the Union.”
Not intimidated by Jackson’s threat to use force to enforce the tariff laws, the South Carolina legislature mobilized the state militia.
The Force Act
With the situation at an impasse, approximately two months later, Congress weighed in by enacting “An Act further to provide for the collection of duties on imports” on March 2, 1833. Commonly known as the Force Act, the legislation authorized “the president to use armed forces to protect customs officers and to prevent the unauthorized removal of untaxed vessels and cargo” in violation of the Tariffs of 1828 and 1832.
Outcome of the Nullification Crisis
With the nation teetering on the brink of civil war, Senator Henry Clay from Kentucky and Senator John C. Calhoun from South Carolina hurriedly brokered a compromise measure to diffuse the situation. Congress designed the new tariff — the Compromise Tariff of 1833 — to reduce protectionist duties gradually until 1842. In 1842, all duties would revert to a uniform level in line with the Tariff of 1816. The compromise provided Southerners the tariff relief they sought while giving domestic manufacturers nine years to adjust to reduced government protection when competing with foreign rivals.
Aftermath of the Nullification Crisis
Unable to muster support from the other Southern States, South Carolina adopted a more conciliatory stance after the enactment of the Tariff of 1833. On March 11, 1833, the Convention of the People of South Carolina re-convened in Columbia. Satisfied that their rebellious stance had forced Congress to bend to their will, the delegates voted 153-4 to rescind the Nullification Ordinance on March 15, 1933.
Although the convention repealed the Nullification Ordinance, it did not repudiate the doctrine of nullification. Before dissolving the convention on March 18, 1833, the delegates approved an ordinance nullifying the Force Act by a vote of 132-19. With bloodshed averted, and the Union preserved, President Jackson wisely ignored the convention’s final act of defiance. Still, the issues of nullification and secession remained undecided, and the ominous specter of civil war lingered on the horizon.
Significance of the Nullification Crisis
The Nullification Crisis was important because it was the first time a dispute between the Federal Government and a state government teetered on the verge of civil war. Although the Tariff of 1833 helped ease tensions, it did not resolve the regional differences between the North and the South, nor did it resolve the issue of state’s rights. When South Carolina threatened secession and passed the Ordinance of Nullification it set a precedent for future disputes between the Federal Government and the states. President Jackson’s handling of the Nullification Crisis also led to his political opponents forming the Whig Party.